Excellence Oyster Bay Review

From Victoria E, Vermont

Already dying to go back to Oyster Bay!

Our 2nd trip to Montego Bay area and by far, the best one yet! Excellence Oyster Bay was a slice of heaven we are already dying to go back to. We cannot express how beautiful the property was, the interior design, the pools and restaurants are all so gorgeous. We stayed in a Beach House, which was amazing, pretty private (walls a little thin, and you can hear neighbors if you are both on the balconies…but that is expected of any hotel, etc.). We had already upgraded to the Excellence Club, which gives you access to Magna and Zenith restaurants (better cuts of meat, better seafood and better breakfast menu) as well as an exclusive smaller pool area, cabana area, clubhouse and bar. I took advantage of the spa, which was beautiful, calming, and the hydrotherapy session is well worth it! Spice restaurant was one of our favorites, as well as Magna and the Aroma coffee bar. Island time is a real thing, get used to waiting 15-20 min in between courses at all meals, but the scenery is well worth any wait at the restaurants…The staff was phenomenal. So wonderful, attentive and one day when it was raining one of the staff taught us how to play dominoes. If you are looking for quiet pool days, I recommend the “non-swim-up-bar” side of the pool, or the Excellence Club pools or the beach, there is a DJ and games being played all morning with a loud speaker set up every day at the main pool.


The beach is clean and good for long walks. Gift shop is cheesy and recommend skipping, better stuff at the airport. Cigar shop is okay, small, good selection, but nothing kept in humidors. We went in early October (the rainy season) so be prepared for rainy afternoons, but it kept us from getting sunburnt! Wifi is good all over the resort, cable channel selection is limited, but again, not the reason we were in Jamaica. We did the “dinner on the beach” for our anniversary, it was storming so they moved us and other couples on the terrace at the Excellence Club, still wonderful. Men Beware: Bring long pants and closed-toes shoes (not sneakers) you MUST dress accordingly to be admitted to restaurants. Women have much more flexibility. Love this resort, will 1000% go again, hopefully soon.

We booked our trip through Berwick Travel (family-owned travel agency specializing in the Caribbean) – we’ve used them 3 times now and they always do a wonderful job setting up private transfer to and from airport, special touches like champagne and fruit upon arrival, breakfast in bed and romantic dinner on the beach, etc. Highly recommend!

Share this post:

Call Now Button
Enjoying this content? Want great travel deals?
Get more articles like this, plus our top deals & promotions, delivered straight to your inbox!
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime - but we promise, they're great deals!
Want the best travel deals?
Get our top deals & promotions, plus travel tips & news, delivered straight to your inbox!

You can unsbcribe at any time.

Want the best travel deals?

Get our best deals & promotions, plus travel tips & news, delivered straight to your inbox!

We understand that this is an unprecedented time in the travel industry. We want you to know we are here for you and you can plan your future trip with confidence. Berwick Travel offers:

• Low Deposits and Payment Plans

• Cancel for Any Reason Travel Protection

• No Consultation or Planning Fees

• A Dedicated Travel Consultant, Start to Finish

Features and benefits may vary based on travel dates, destination, resort, or vacation type.

Let us help!

Scroll to Top